Guide

Social value in construction tenders

Social value is now a discipline of its own, not an appendix to sustainability. This guide covers how UK construction buyers score it, how measurement frameworks such as TOMs work, what separates a top-band answer from a policy statement, and how to keep commitments deliverable.

1. What buyers mean by social value

Social value is the additional benefit a contract generates for the community it is delivered in — jobs and training for local people, spend retained in the local economy and with smaller businesses, support for community organisations and schools, and environmental improvement beyond regulatory minimums.

The policy direction is established: public buyers are expected to consider wider benefit alongside cost, and central government procurement policy has set a minimum weighting for social value in its own competitions. The Procurement Act 2023's Most Advantageous Tender basis reinforces this by making it explicit that award need not default to lowest price.

For a bidder the practical consequence is narrow: social value is a scored criterion with a published weighting and band descriptors, and it is marked the same way every other criterion is marked. Treat it as a technical answer, not a values statement.

2. Measurement frameworks and TOMs

Most UK construction clients ask for commitments in measurable units rather than prose. The Themes, Outcomes and Measures (TOMs) framework is the most commonly encountered: it groups measures under themes such as local jobs, skills, supply chain, environment and community, and attaches a proxy financial value to each measure so bids can be compared on a common basis.

Buyers differ in how they use it. Some ask you to select measures and state quantities, then score the total proxy value. Some publish a required set of measures. Some ignore TOMs entirely and score a narrative against band descriptors. Some ask for a plan plus a commitment table. Read the ITT and answer in the format it asks for — a TOMs table submitted where a narrative was requested scores as a non-answer, and vice versa.

Where proxy values are scored, understand what drives the total: sustained employment and apprenticeship weeks typically carry far more proxy value than one-off volunteering days, so a bid stuffed with school visits can lose to one with two apprenticeships.

3. What separates a top-band answer

Across UK construction evaluations, high-scoring social value answers share five properties. Each maps to something an evaluator can tick.

  • Specific to this contract. Commitments sized to this project's value, duration and workforce — not a corporate annual total.
  • Local. Named wards, boroughs or travel-to-work areas, named local colleges, named local suppliers or supplier categories.
  • Measurable. Numbers with units and timing: two apprenticeships starting in month three, 45 weeks of placement, £X of spend within 20 miles.
  • Owned. A named role accountable for delivery, and where it sits in the project governance.
  • Evidenced. Proof the same commitments were delivered before, with actual numbers from a comparable contract.

The corresponding failure list is short and predictable: national statistics with no local hook, "we will endeavour to", volunteering hours with no beneficiary named, and a sustainability answer recycled into the social value box.

4. A structure that works

Where the ITT does not mandate a format, this order maps cleanly onto most band descriptors:

  1. Local baseline. Two or three sentences showing you understand this locality's specific priorities — unemployment, skills shortages, the client's own published strategy.
  2. Commitment table. Measure, quantity, timing, owner. Aligned to the buyer's measures where they are published.
  3. Delivery mechanism. How each commitment is actually achieved — which partner, which recruitment route, which supply-chain clause.
  4. Governance and reporting. Who tracks it, at what frequency, in which report, and what happens if a measure slips.
  5. Evidence. A comparable contract with actual delivered numbers.

Keep the table inside the word or page limit. Where a limit exists, evidence that falls beyond it is routinely not read — put the numbers before the cut, not in an appendix.

5. Keep it deliverable

Committed measures are frequently written into the contract and tracked as KPIs, and performance is increasingly visible through contract performance notices. Over-committing to win is therefore a two-stage mistake: it exposes you to under-delivery on this contract and weakens the evidence base for the next bid.

Practical control: before submission, have the intended project manager and the person who will actually recruit sign off every number in the commitment table. If neither will sign, the number does not go in.

FAQ

What is social value in a construction tender?
Social value is the wider social, economic and environmental benefit a contract delivers beyond the works themselves — local employment and training, spend with local and smaller suppliers, community engagement, and environmental improvement. In UK public procurement it is usually a separately weighted, scored criterion.
How much of the score is social value?
It varies by buyer and contract. Central government has applied a minimum weighting to social value under its procurement policy, and construction clients commonly weight it somewhere in the range of five to twenty per cent of the quality score. The only number that matters is the one published in your ITT.
What is the TOMs framework?
TOMs stands for Themes, Outcomes and Measures — a widely used social value measurement framework that assigns proxy financial values to specific measures, such as weeks of apprenticeship provided or local spend delivered. Many UK buyers ask bidders to commit against selected TOMs measures and report against them during delivery.
Why do social value answers score badly?
Because they describe corporate policy rather than contract-specific commitments. Evaluators reward numbers tied to this project, this locality and a named owner, with a delivery mechanism and a reporting method. Generic statements about being a responsible employer score at the bottom of the band range almost everywhere.
Are social value commitments contractual?
Frequently, yes. Committed measures are often written into the contract and tracked as KPIs, and under-delivery can affect performance records and future award. Only commit to what your delivery team has agreed it can achieve on this contract.

Score your bid before the evaluator does

TendersIQ UK reads your tender documents, rebuilds the published scoring framework, and marks your draft answers against it — criterion by criterion, with the quote that earned the band.

Free tools for this

No sign-up, nothing stored — everything runs in your browser.